12 Comments
User's avatar
Jeanne's avatar

Absolutely the best Substack of the week. A+

Vlad M's avatar

What a terrible thing; to be conscious...

Mercer's avatar

the squirrel metaphor at the opening is doing something most writers would not risk - it takes a dead-serious argument about sexual super-stimuli and grounds it in something absurd enough to disarm the reader before the real blade arrives. the move from the goose's supernormal egg to instagram face is one of the sharper analogical transitions i have read on this topic.

what struck me is the observation that incels have never encountered a couple who believably rejected the sexual black market. that absence is the real tragedy. they are not just angry about being excluded from the game. they have concluded that the game is the only reality, because nobody showed them what a genuine alternative looks like. the nihilism is not about sex. it is about the absence of a visible counter-model.

the line about tying a feather duster to the squirrel's tail to make him don juan is going to stay with me for a while.

Will Romano's avatar

Nice, man made horrors beyond my comprehension 😃

Randall Bennington's avatar

>If you’ve ever seen it, “Instagram face,” is hyper-attractive on camera and yet looks strangely “2D” in real life.

I used to work on the floor below Ford Models, so i would see these people in the elevator every day. In the flesh, there was always something off; I called it the uncanny valley, but 2D is a good description. This essay is a good frame for an idea I've been struggling with - Beauty is a deception. I don't agree with that idea, but that is what super-stumuli looksmaxxing is attempting. You can see the line in real life, real flesh, but digitally, the line cannot be perceived. So to looksmaxx is to plug yourself into the Matrix (blue pill), because it's the only place where you can be beautiful to yourself.

Sophie Blackwell's avatar

There’s something almost endearing about how men intellectualize their own panic. Dress it up in biology, myth, operas, incels, super‑stimuli — anything to avoid saying the simpler thing: we built a world that makes everyone feel replaceable, and now we’re shocked that it’s eating us alive. I don’t disagree with the diagnosis; I just think women have been living inside the fallout for decades without needing a cosmology to explain it. Still, it’s interesting to watch the language evolve. The metaphors get sharper every year, which tells me the discomfort is finally landing where it belongs.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Who's "we?" How did we build it? You think women had nothing to do with it?

autonoes's avatar

Don Juan ! (not Quixote)

Corvin's avatar

Was up to make the same comment

Soph's avatar

this was amazing. such an interesting insight. I also wrote something similar to yours. would love to know your thoughts! https://k44rl44.substack.com/p/i-consumed-looksmaxxing-content-for?utm_campaign=post-expanded-share&utm_medium=web

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 30
Comment deleted
Riley Foreman's avatar

I love this one. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.