I’ve had many experiences in my life that can only be described as ‘mystical’ or ‘supernatural’. But it can be difficult to talk about these experiences without sounding insane or woo-woo or terribly self-involved.
Fortunately, I’m not stuck trying to figure this out on my own. I’ve asked the ever-insightful James Taylor Foreman to help me untangle the nebulous knot of mystical experiences. Below is our dialogue, a format I much prefer to the ‘podcast’.
AAK
Okay, James. We’ve both had what we would call ‘mystical experiences’, and while it can feel tricky to write about them to a wider audience, my guess is they aren’t as unusual as we think. If we broaden the definition of ‘mystic’ just a bit, we find that many people have had an experience they cannot quite explain, that doesn’t quite align with rational materialism (i.e. seeing ghosts, hearing voices, prophetic dreams, etc.). To my mind, there are two ways this happens:
You’re in a heightened state of emotion or altered brain chemistry which makes you more perceptive of non-rational occurrences.
You are intensely focused and in the flow of an activity or meditation or contemplation so that your mind is very quiet, and you are caught off guard by something you’ve never seen before.
What do you think? Are mystical experiences actually commonplace and we just filter them out because we don’t have a good way of understanding them? Or are there different categories of mystical experience and some are more meaningful than others? And how do these personal experiences all fit into more mainstream religion?
***note: the rest of this article is ‘free-walled’, which means the dialogue will appear below after you take out a free or paid subscription to Waymarkers.***

Do our experiences and thinking align with your own ‘spiritual’ or ‘mystical’ or ‘unexplainable’ experiences? Let us know in the comments, as this is something we’re both interested in understanding beyond our own perspectives…


