41 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Duplantier's avatar

I've known people with IQs over 130. One has been a friend, in some ways, for fifty years. He never got less than an A on a test and scored near-perfectly on the major college entrance exams. He turned those gifts into a lucrative career as a board-certified cardiologist. For fun, he could explain derivatives and Jimi Hendrix licks.

But he was also kind and generous in ways you didn't always see coming. He'd buy dinner for the whole gang, pay for Van Halen tickets when you couldn't afford them, or drive a little too fast in his Ferrari so you could experience the thrill of it yourself.

I knew at fifteen that I wasn't going to be that guy intellectually. But I've had a long time to think about what intelligence means, and whether we've given it too much importance.

Being smarter than the rest of us is one thing. What you do with it, and how you treat people along the way, is something else.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

So true, Daniel. Intelligence being bound by responsibility to be good to people, keeps it from being too terrifying. I’ve also known people like that who make me realize that I’m not nearly as smart as I think I am. Always humbling.

Mark Engleson's avatar

The point about the eccentric genius is a good one. My family is full of scholars, scientists, artists. Ivy League professors. Child prodigies starting at Cornell and Chicago at 16. The best of us are quirky, but many of these people are unsufferable ("mean," "asshole," and "bastard" have been thrown around), and descriptions of the craziest stuff have been called "psychotic."

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Can’t even imagine that. Not a scholarly family line over here. Did you feel that as pressure to be a genius yourself?

Mark Engleson's avatar

I kind of am. Maxed on every verbal measure. Reading Philip Roth at 13 - my uncle gave me Portnoy's Complaint (the weirdness). I would score so well on tests the teacher had to ignore it to set the curve. I recently shared a verse I wrote Neko Case on her substack and she liked it. I think I wrote it in 10 minutes. I don't have superior autobiographical memory, but my memory is on the fringes. I have no problem recalling full details of interactions from before the pandemic - verbatim.

My spatial reasoning is terrible though, so I hit a wall with geometry. My mother made ne sit with her at the dinner table and work on it with her until I was crying. And she made me keep working at it.

I also had a lot of problems to work through. I'm a ball of ASD, ADHD, PTSD, and chronic anxiety. I was a weird, neurodivent, genius Jewish kid in the suburbs of Akron in the 80s and 90s and went through extreme bullying. There's a fair bit of Dylan, Harlan Ellison, Steve Earle, and Tom Waits in me, and it took a while to figure out how to make it work.

⁰

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

This is why we hate the idea of IQ (and punish it). What a terrifying person you are. I'm sure that's been alienating.

Mark Engleson's avatar

I'm a 5-4 chonky dude who looks like Jack Black's Wario. I'm a human muppet! (And yeah, not hitting 5’ until my last year of high school sucked, too.)

Alienation: freshman year of college, someone asked my SAT. I was too inept to spot the trap and answered.

He looked at me like I was an alien.

It's better as adult. Finding my people. I can and have flirted with Margaret Atwood… but I have to be in my element.

Jason Killingsworth's avatar

You've written a lovely companion piece to the David Sedaris essay "(I Used to Be) A Smart Guy": https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/a198/used-smart-guy-1199/

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Huge compliment - I wish I could write like Sedaris.

Rick's avatar

You touch on this, and I think it's something that the lone genius/IQ-over-all types fail to appreciate: we're all embedded in cultures and traditions, and those foundational structures are far far far more important to our intellectual/cultural productivity than the traits of one individual smarty-pants. (Related, the famous Gould quote about the whorls of Einstein's brain.) One guy just cannot do that much alone. Myth-making around science is fun but leads people to be confused about what actually drives scientific or technological progress.

Separately, people will often say that we have fewer geniuses now and that we're no longer making good scientific progress. I think we might actually just have been quite successful at picking most of the low-hanging fruit. Most fields are now so difficult and deep that a von Neumann could no longer flit from field to field, turning them upside down and moving on. That's not an indictment of our scientific progress; it's a positive indicator.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Great points, but I'm still convinced that destorying aristocratic cultures in favor of flat ones probably cut off our access to the most instances of the highest levels of genius.

Rick's avatar

I think this is what Erik Hoel talks about with aristocratic tutoring, right? It's a pretty interesting idea! Not sure I'm convinced of it, but I'm Silicon Valley-brained enough to be drawn to the idea of tutoring a kid from an early age into incredible skill.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

That’s exactly right yes. I linked it around the time I brought it up in the piece.

J.E. Petersen's avatar

So you’re saying: it’s good to be smart, but it’s better to be good.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

It’s fine to be smart, but you can’t really become smart. But it’s great to be good, and you can become good.

Askewnaut's avatar

great article. like all forms of power and freedom, iq is instrumental. it is not a good in and of itself. in fact and of course, it can be wasted or used for great good or evil. it must be used for The Good. great power/ great responsibility, etc.

chayote tacos's avatar

Thoughtful and interesting thank you!!

Kevin O'Driscoll's avatar

James, your ordinary life point matters. Children who get an answer quickly still have to learn what to do when friends need longer. Being able to see where someone has gone wrong doesn’t teach how to help them gently and humbly. There’s a lot of maturing in learning how to use an ability to serve others.

My son is high IQ, and watching him play sport helped me see this, because on the pitch he needs his teammates, and they need him. He gets to belong without IQ becoming the thing that defines him. We owe children that freedom.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Excellent points and glad your son has a father with good sense about his gifts.

Hutch's avatar
3dEdited

GMU economist Garrett Jones's “The Hive Mind Paradox: How Your Nation’s IQ Matters So Much More Than Your Own” would seem to align with your point that individual genius matters less than the society in which it is cultivated.

Steven's avatar

I’m surprised you seem dismissive of Taleb’s case; he is, in a way, in your corner, that IQ measures something but not what matters (and it’s not even a good measure of what it claims to).

(Btw Einstein and Mozart are not really fair examples of high IQ = genius output, are they? neither took an IQ test! — Feynman, who did, famously scored 125.)

Anyway I love the message of this essay but I guess I’d encourage you to be even more skeptical of IQ. 🤌

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

of his case, not his intution. His argument that it doesn’t measure high intelligence well is wrong IMO

And estimating historical figure’s IQ is rough but probably pretty accurate. It’s not hard to get a pretty damn accurate idea of someone’s IQ, despite how mysterious people make it seem.

Brad Klingele's avatar

Sigh; the “ordinary” people is the best part of this essay, and explains the rest. There are numerical / statistical words that could have been employed but weren't and that is what makes the rest of the essay so unlike the better essays. I have found that people with high IQ’s think this way and it usually makes the people very boring in the long run, with fewer and fewer creative insights because they have done things with ease and, being successful in their fields, are unaware of how they don't reach beyond their increasingly deep trench.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

I only do my best to communicate, Brad. I apologize for not always hitting the mark.

Brad Klingele's avatar

Interestingly, you may well be a genius; I just find the IQ stuff so odious and references to it so suspect, for a myriad of reasons. And it's not unlikely that it’s so awful from my experiences that I had an allergic reaction; to some cilantro is soap.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Appreciate that. If it seems that way at all, it's just because I've practiced writing more than almost anyone. Really, my starting point was only slightly above average.

Brad Klingele's avatar

We are all like this; I’m an asshole murderer and arrogant. And loved. It's good to see the mirror. But as an essay, it isn't what is so fetching about you and your writing.

chayote tacos's avatar

Brad, could you save a bit more? I’m curious.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 10
Comment deleted
James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Well, I never place myself anywhere but "ordinary" and am candid about the fact that I used to wish I were a genius, but I'm not. I also land against IQ as a measure and say that fixating on it is self-defeating.

chayote tacos's avatar

Very helpful thank you so much! I definitely appreciate the point that genius occurs at all IQ levels. Absolutely true but also sorely misunderstood at all levels of popular culture as well as intellectual culture.

Elizabeth Gilbert may have hit the mark much better when she points out that I think the etymology of genius was like a sort of muse that came to inspire you at certain times.

I greatly appreciate the exchange as well, even before supposed LLM writing took over everything humans already were writing terribly at all levels. So I appreciate good writing , and this is clearly not written by software…. so thank you all for the exchange.

(I spend a lot of time saving time using software enhanced writing so I feel very comfortable risking of these assumptions).

(Have a good weekend, or hurricane sheltering, wherever y'all may be)

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 10
Comment deleted
Liam Riley's avatar

I had to go back and read again as I got a different impression from the one you're describing. The comparison of outlier and normal certainly didn't seem insulting to either in context. I read the reference to "ordinary life" as a focus on more quotidian matters rather than belittling of that, indeed the point I read was that the benefits of great natural capability are often stifled in the face of a disorderly or harmful everyday environment.