49 Comments
User's avatar
Justin Ross's avatar

As they say in finance, the cure for high prices is high prices.

The cure for hyper-turbo-liberalism is the fact that it makes itself an unbearably self-centered, childish, vapid culture that people actively want to escape from. It's the pendulum inevitably swinging back.

And as you said, there are those who get it and those who don't, and those who don't aren't worth arguing with. Because those of us who do can just... go be happy.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Just commenting on this so it’ll show up first in the comments. This is exactly spot on.

Tyler David Rigdon's avatar

“The vibe shift I’m experiencing is that the heaviness of being is not only bearable, but preferred.”

Cool article man. And relatable. I’ve been hesitant about calling it a revival too, despite that word being thrown around a lot, but what’s undoubtable is something is happening. I too would have never seen myself in my situation five years ago—similar to yours—but I am, and I’m elated about it, and people I know are doing it too, and strangers are popping up in my life all over who “get it.” Or, feel it. I live part of the year in a very liberal metro area in the United States and just this week saw two separate people younger than me reading CS Lewis on public transit, and that was on my way home from Mass. This just didn’t happen ten years ago and yet it’s happening in this strange immeasurable way.

Randy Brison's avatar

As a 67-year-old, I find myself irrationally happy with this thought - young people are reading C.S. Lewis - thank you for sharing, and thank God!

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

As someone else pointed out, there is definately something going on with people, even outside of the church. Intellectuals interested in theology again, etc.

Tyler David Rigdon's avatar

Absolutely. The type of person who was just a blatant atheist in 2011 is now a non-Christian theist, or “exploring religion,” or something like that. Lot of reasons for that; the absolute atomic frying of the moral landscape due to the onslaught of materialist and “New Atheist” rhetoric from the aughts is surely amongst them. There really is no debate surrounding the state of cultural decay nowadays, except from a small subset of the far left who believe unlimited freedom is the path to utopia but not sure many people take that seriously. Even the rational left will you something is “off”. And the proof is in the pudding, look around: The Media age, smartphone addiction, and empowerment of the so-called ordinary individual to live exactly how they want all the time is seismically devastating for the foundation this culture is built on, we can’t withstand it. We’ve lost the plot, literally. People need grounding, they need transcendence, and it’s apparent that even those who don’t reach first for Christ, are reaching up, and that’s a decent sign.

Al DuClur's avatar

Fascinating post. I am a much hated boomer who was a kid in the 60s. I see a big difference between the cultural impact of the hippies and what is going on now with the young.

The hippies were a top down cultural revolution while the current trend you describe is bottom up. Few people were hippies. The epicenter of hippydom was laurel canyon and a disproportionate number of them were children of high ranking military and intelligence parents. The best example is probably Jim Morrison whose father was Admiral Morrison. Hippies cultural values had the media, Hollywood, CIA and universities to build on the movement.

So, the hippies were elite sanctioned rebels. Young people now rejecting the current culture and moving more to a traditional way of viewing the world are more likely to be rebels. Problem is they are going against the wishes of the elite and all the institutions. It will be much harder for them to have a cultural impact.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Excellent, I never would have thought of this.

Corné Gieselbach's avatar

This reads like a wonderful conversation with a friend excited to tell me what they have stimmed on recently but they do it with a deep care for my soul.

Lil John's avatar

“the only thing that makes the Church endurable is that it is somehow the body of Christ and that on this we are fed. It seems to be a fact that you have to suffer as much from the Church as for it”

Rich Haas's avatar

Well written and well reasoned. The vibe here in NE Georgia is young family men coming out like clockwork to Sunday services, and volunteering themselves to serve in the life of the church and mentor one another. It is a joy for an old guy like me to see, a prayer answered!

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

You're a good one, Rich!

Aron Ravin's avatar

You put this far better than I did. Well done!

Jacob the Weird's avatar

The vibe is threshing the chaff from tue wheat

Justin Veazey's avatar

A book that led me to this place…

Acedia and Its Discontents: Metaphysical Boredom in an Empire of Desire by R.J. Snellhttps://www.goodreads.com/book/show/25502617-acedia-and-its-discontents

Jonathan's avatar

A fantastic book, which I happily purchased and read several years ago!

Douglas E. Dye's avatar

A most enlightening, edifying, and entertaining essay, Mr. Foreman. Thank you. Godspeed.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Godspeed to you, sir.

Daniel Duplantier's avatar

I like the fringes. You can watch without having to join, and you’re not lost in the middle of the crowd. Maybe we’re all pulled toward the attractor that gives us what we want. These days, it’s fashionable to call yourself a recovering Catholic while tithing at the local megachurch. But the old Church still offers mystery in its rituals, comfort in its litanies, and community in those monotone recitations. Maybe the fringe isn’t the crust of society, but the chewy edge of a Hubig’s pie. There’s something to be said for staying out of the middle.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

I like the fringes as well, Daniel. But I think that’s a temperament thing.

Daniel Duplantier's avatar

For sure! The edges became a place I could hide since I was never alpha enough back when it mattered.

Mike Hottell's avatar

Disaffected young men are the mission field

Barbelo of the Pleroma's avatar

Loved this. Hearing a sung Latin mass brought me back to the Church after 30 years, and now I cantor in the schola. My family and I find it incredibly beautiful, and I can't believe that, in my childhood, this priceless ceremony had been replaced with guitar slop and honky arrangements of spirituals. I am ready to play the long game.

Tyler Pellom's avatar

I listen to a lot of finance podcasts, and read a lot of finance books/newsletters, and often there is a path in which a young man takes on the word via Wall Street, makes a lot of money, then realized later on that his wife and kids actually hate him and he has no close friends. They then start talking about "mindfulness" and playing by their "inner score card."

What you're describing feels close to that to me. I am not religious -- so maybe I am purposefully ignoring that piece of the pie -- but I think it is natural at 30, 40, 50, etc., to recalculate your priorities and decide "hey, maybe I need a real purpose/community."

I am 32, and I assume you are close to my age (if not, please correct me), and I think our age demographic is particularly keen on this, given we grew up in the social media generation, and then watched COVID destroy much of what we thought we knew about the world.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Yes, close to my age. I agree that there is something that shifts with age and that it's universal, but that also seems to be dovetailing into a cultural moment.

Kevin Hembree's avatar

Right on. I think I’ll reread Walker Percy’s the Last Gentleman this afternoon.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Let me know how it is.

Minnesota Brian's avatar

This was phenomenal