77 Comments
User's avatar
JasonT's avatar

The law of diminishing returns has not yet been repealed.

Jack's avatar

Thought there will be this C.S Lewis quote at the end, fits perfectly:

"If we are all going to be destroyed by an atomic bomb, let that bomb when it comes find us doing sensible and human things praying, working, teaching, reading, listening to music, bathing the children, playing tennis, chatting to our friends over a pint and a game of darts—not huddled together like frightened sheep and thinking about bombs. They may break our bodies (a microbe can do that) but they need not dominate our minds."

Riley Foreman's avatar

This quote is truly one of the most formative philosophies I abide by.

Auguste Meyrat's avatar

I was having these same thoughts about the decline of interest in new videogames. Like you, I was nearly obsessed with the the Gameboy Color, Gamecube, and all the rest of it--though my family wisely discouraged me from spending too much time on these things. Even now, more than two decades later, I can't really feel that bad about it. I felt genuine excitement and satisfaction with these past-times. Good times! This feeling is a lot more muted now, and it's for things that are relatively boring like reading a good essay (like this one) or winning a game of Sushi Go.

I agree that AI seems to be following the same trajectory. I never had fears that it would overtake humanity and transform the world beyond recognition. I do worry that may devastate Gen Z who are coming to rely on it to complete their education, but this is probably because I'm a teacher who cares about this kind of thing.

And yes, us Millennial parents are far less trusting of incorporating so many "smart" products and screens into our households. My kids have none of those things and are growing up far more traditionally that I did. They're innocent, curious, and creative. I recommend this for any parent even it it requires more involvement than they may be comfortable with.

Brothers Krynn - Fiction's avatar

This is my plan when I've kids. No screens, maybe tv once a week but mostly gonna raise them with books and the outdoors.

Randy M's avatar

I get a lot of ads telling me that now, using AI, I can design any kind of app I can imagine.

Maybe it's a failure of imagination, but my life doesn't suffer a dearth of apps.

(Unless they're nachos)

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

lol. Same for me, Randy. Really interesting how much people brag about vibe coding on Claude and yet I’ve never needed or wanted anything they produced.

Matt GK's avatar

This is one of the MAIN things I constantly think about- if AI is so transformative and incredibly innovative can literally anyone point to a single thing anyone has made using it that didn’t fundamentally already exist in a perfectly usable form? What amazing apps or websites or art have been made with LLMs? I’m a musician and for all the talk I hear about vibe coding etc not a single new plugin or app or musical tool has been made since the widespread adoption of LLMs that has dramatically or even noticeably moved those fields along; all the best and most widely adapted tools are things that were made traditionally. The whole proposition of AI justifying it’s absurd valuation kind of requires it to be able to do things that span beyond “nifty” or “pretty helpful if you double check it”

erg art ink's avatar

They lost me at the watch, and intrusive wearable devices. Which I have referred to as my electronic leashes professionally. That said I remember the thrill of walking home late at night wearing a Walkman. Music that could travel with me anywhere.

When did this obsessive greed start?

Very apt; “Informationally obese, ready for a digital diet.”

Jon Besga's avatar

Glorious article. You should be proud of your writing! My childhood resonated a lot while reading the beginning and I pretty much agree with your last conclusions. I've been excited by tech for a long time but not that much lately. I feels that we are not getting as much "bang for the buck" as we used to get with tech in the 2000s.

Antonia's avatar

Thank you for articulating these thoughts so beautifully. I feel that at the moment it’s not popular to argue against “the singularity” using the heuristic of the technology adoption sigmoid trend. But this essay actually has a long time horizon perspective, which really helps. It’s true, life is already digitally saturated! what else could these clankers do…

Laredo Davis's avatar

Great read! My favorite was the ending and not in a rude way. I loved how you wrapped it up with: Even if that’s not true, and everything is suddenly taken away from me in an AI apocalypse, at least I’ll die with people I love, doing normal things.

I too will be content. If that is the end for my family and I. Doing normal things!

J-Murf's avatar

"A lot of them semi-religiously believe they’ll get to live forever in some abstract super-world where they never pay the cost of being weird at parties." These words <3

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

As a former believer, I can vouch for that characterization

Mandy Murray's avatar

I thought Nah when Zuckerberg did the meta verse or something that was incredibly boring. So much of current culture is churning out previous decades of stuff. We will move through and out the other side.

Jarvis News's avatar

That diminishing-returns line is sharp. It fits the piece's hot-water idea too: once novelty fades, people stop chasing the upgrade and care more about what the tech was supposed to free them up to do.

Obscure Art and Music's avatar

I will say that I feel it was exceptionally fast to get to diminishing returns with AI for my projects. Surely it made a bunch of progress really fast but then it very quickly hit a wall where I had done everything I needed to do with it.

Mitch's avatar

I'm an engineer and let me just say that you're absolutely right in so many ways. There's a lot I want to expand upon, though, and I ended up writing a small essay in the comment box (poor design incentives, socioeconomic constraints on new technology v. hard physical limits, etc.). Leaving this comment as a commitment to actually flesh out that piece in the near future 🫡

John the Nazirite's avatar

What came to mind was Ecclesiastics - that diatribe to ennui by Solomon: Ecclesiastes 12:3-8

in the day when the keepers of the house tremble, and the strong men are bent, and the grinders cease because they are few … the grasshopper drags itself along, and desire fails, because man is going to his eternal home, and the mourners go about the streets—before the silver cord is snapped, or the golden bowl is broken, or the pitcher is shattered at the fountain, or the wheel broken at the cistern, and the dust returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns to God who gave it. Vanity of vanities, says the Preacher; all is vanity.

Brady Dale's avatar

I don’t know that I think this is right, but I appreciate it

zakariya's avatar

A great, grounding read, especially when our algorithms all point to and confirm this technological absolutism. At the end of the day, it's circular, though. Retreat from the machines and you see that. The ebbs and flows of all these predicted singularities that we've conjured up over the centuries only seem so big as we pass through them. See beyond them and observe that perhaps - and I know I can't quite prove this in any way - there's something much more basic and intrinsic to humans than the tools we use to satiate our desires.