32 Comments
User's avatar
Perplexed Pachyderm's avatar

Old and bitter Carlin was definitely less funny for his didactism, but early punny Carlin is hard to beat for his obsession with the sheer absurdity of language and grammar. Werds is a masterclass in extracting fascinating little nuggets out of everyday language.

Blurb_Birb's avatar

Providence, I've often told people, works for the funniest outcome.

GM's avatar

Thank God someone with a sufficient mind and platform finally says what has long been overdue.

George Carlin isn't funny. Not even a little bit. His "comedy" was just the rantings of an embittered old cynic for a crowd of other cynics who thought themselves to be much more clever than they really were. It was comedy that was to be cheered and clapped to out of smug agreement rather than any sincere "Aha!" laughter.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

I took a swing with that. I totally agree with your take here.

Alec Classen's avatar

Halfway through this I was reminded of the famous Wodehouse line:

“At that moment, however, the drowsy stillness of the summer afternoon was shattered by what sounded to his strained senses like J. T. Foreman falling on a sheet of tin.”

No really, very good and caught echoes of the prince of paradox himself in places.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

If only I had a similar level of sheer girth as our man, Gilbert.

Rick Lewis's avatar

I'm not sure that everyone wants to be funny. I sat next to a guy on a plane years ago who started telling me about his hunting hobby in graphic detail. I casually mentioned I was a vegetarian and hunting wasn't really my bag. He didn't miss a beat. He looked me in my eyes, and with straight-faced conviction said, "If god didn't want us to eat animals he wouldna made em outta meat." No smirk of mischief or sense that we was trying to be funny. Indeed, reality can be hilarious.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

As I say, interesting is on the way to funny. It seems that humor is how we orient all our attention. We focus on what humors us. Hilarious is just an extreme form of attention. What keeps even a scientist focused is a million little micro-laughs. That’s the pathway to all discovery.

Aaron James Weisel's avatar

David Foster Wallace cared a lot about the virtue of attention and found mundane things to be intensely interesting—consequently his writing is hilarious

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

DFW was the funniest writer

Domestic Blitz ☦️'s avatar

This reminds me of the Mel Brooks joke in History of the World about the “Stand-up Philosophers”

Also thinking about The Comedian in Watchmen.

People who are truly funny are often those who are physically incapable of abstaining from noticing hard truths and uncomfortable realities.

Sethu Iyer's avatar

Hey, Søren Kierkegaard is absolutely a laugh riot.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Probably even more true in his native language

Sethu Iyer's avatar

I like how the Hongs’ edition puts the original Danish in brackets when the puns are untranslatable.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

This reminds me of a broader point that most of the great works of literature are hilarious, and I feel like it typically flies over the heads of self serious scholars

Live And Learn With Henry's avatar

Patrick McManus, Terry Pratchett, and G.K. Chesterton all come to mind as men who found profound joy in the most mundane of things.

Rick Olivier's avatar

I haven't followed him all that closely but Reggie Watts' reminds us that every moment of every day is improvised in multiple small ways. I'd do five minutes (or one if I got the hook) in Jackson. https://somebodysome1.bandcamp.com/album/the-best-of-reggie-watts-improv-ep

Dave the barnacle's avatar

You should check out “Impro for Storytellers” by Keith Johnstone. It’s full of improv exercises and activities with discussions about why they work . . .

Fr. Brad Doyle's avatar

Look up the “Risus Paschalis” (The Easter Laugh)

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

Now you have to do a raunchy standup homily this Easter. It’s actually super Trad.

Fr. Brad Doyle's avatar

You can ghost write it for me.

Andy the Alchemist's avatar

Calling George Carlin unfunny is my definition of blasphemy. Otherwise I agree with a lot of what you have said here. The best comics are in many ways the most honest ones. To be able to see the beauty and absurdity of life clearly and also be able to translate that perspective to others is a subtle but very powerful skill.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

I knew some people wouldn’t like that ha.

Schlicting's avatar

I think it must be an age thing. I’m in my 70’s and grew up with George Carlin. He captured the disconnect and absurdity between the establishment’s narrative and what my generation was experiencing. In his later years his comedy was more “bitter”- maybe because he felt our generation didn’t fulfill our potential.

James Taylor Foreman's avatar

True. I also thought about specifying "late" Carlin, but I've never actually seen him say something that made me laugh. I should probably give him some due respect as someone who did something no one had ever done before, though. I was being a bit too glib, for fun.

Andy the Alchemist's avatar

If all you have seen are clips of his latest years I could see how he comes off a bit as a scold. He was genuinely boundary pushing for his time though, which I still appreciate. I knew you were being flippant with that remark but could not resist the bait.

Anne Hawley's avatar

Super uncomfortable read for me because I'm not one bit funny. I worked my way rather painfully and earnestly through Arthur Koestler's The Act of Creation in an attempt to understand his attempt to understand humor. (Neither of us, I think, got there.)

And yet I laugh my ass off at the DUMBEST stuff--silly puns and dad jokes, cat videos. So I guess the question your essay raises for me is this: if it makes me laugh, is it funny? And if I find things funny, does that suggest I have a sense of humor, even though I never make people laugh myself (at least not deliberately)?