You Are Not Silly People
If you aren’t laughing, you don’t get it.
I didn’t tell anyone this at the time, but I’d ended up living in LA for seven years because I Googled “best comedy school” and the Groundlings popped up. There, I came to know this guy who could get a laugh just by the way he said “yeah.” You had to be there.
The vast majority of the students couldn’t get a chuckle to save their lives, though. There were many theories and classes about how to overcome this, but every one of them had the same flaw: you could follow the system to a tee and still be the least funny person who ever lived.
The philosophers have written theories of humor. To my memory, not one of them was a laugh riot. No surprise. Anybody who sits down to derive the nature of funniness from first principles will almost certainly reveal himself to be unfunny, thereby disproving at least the efficacy of his own theory. But it’s also weird, because humor is one of the most central things about human life. Everyone wants to be funny. Humorless people are notoriously miserable, too. People will even pay thousands of dollars to watch a guy stand alone on a stage and be funnier than average.
So I’ll tell you what I think it is, without making the mistake of claiming I’m very good at it. Humor is the recognition of things as they are. It’s the shock of waking up from a convenient lie, and the simultaneous joy that at least we’re facing it together.
Funny people, on some level and in some partial way, have a habit of actually paying attention. They see past some amount of defenses we put up to protect who we wish we were. In some minor way, that guy could see what was really happening, and through him we could see it too. With him and through him and with each other, we gained some courage to face whatever subtle little thing about ourselves was hiding in the shadows. So we loved it, and we loved him.
This is more broadly important than it seems. Interesting is on the way to funny. You can tell, because very interesting things make you laugh. On this spectrum, you could imagine that the profoundest things must be hilarious. Delight is the state in which our senses are suddenly in highest fidelity to the medium. That could be anywhere from ah to ah-hah, to HA! We have both the solidity of understanding, for a sense of safety, and also the engagement of surprise, in optimal proportion. In the same way, what we spontaneously find interesting, what humors us, is the pathway that leads toward our deepest engagement and therefore our optimal development.
There are at least two ways to fall off this path. One is the path of somber seriousness. This is the sort of person who is a strict traditionalist, knows his orthodoxy, and is currently waiting for you to stop talking so he can recite it. It doesn’t matter if the orthodoxy is Orthodoxy or Science. Trads and dissidents can really know their stuff, don’t get me wrong. A lot of them have good things to say (a lot of them are on Substack). But it sometimes almost feels like a negative miracle how unfunny they are, which is not a compliment to their seriousness, but an indication that they can’t actually see what’s going on.
On some level, they believe their excess of orthodoxy will save them from the dangers of vice, decadence, and chaos. Really, they play into the hands of the very chaos monsters they fight by not being suffciently agile and awake. They unintentionally devote their lives to being unable to engage with the context of a conversation happening right now. Forget all your presuppositions. Believe in nonsense, at least for a moment, and see what happens. Trust, in other words, that there is an order over and above the silly hologram you’ve devised in your own mind. You will feel liberated enough to forget your own approximation of things and thrust yourself into Being as if you never knew anything at all, just to see how it spits you back out. This way, you will become the sort of person who can think rather than the sort of person who hoards shiny facts like a bowerbird.
The opposite mistake is an excess of mockery, the Heckler. You would think that these people side too heavily with chaos. They certainly fancy themselves that way. They are the less-funny heirs of and already unfunny George Carlin, mocking all structures of belief out of existence on the partly reasonable grounds that those structures are, as we’ve already shown via the honest mistake of the Trads, only facsimiles of the actual Truth. They are right to notice this, but Hecklers sometimes go so far as to say that there is no Truth at all. The only thing is cynicism and unbelief, and they are the upside-down kings of that underworld. Now laugh.
This is not funny at all. I mean that technically, because I don’t recognize it as true. It’s also not very different from the mistake of the Trads, though the Hecklers would be deeply offended at the suggestion that they are not that different from the Trads they love to mock. Both, in fact, suffer from an excess of reason. An unbelief in nonsense or an unbelief in sense. Either way, a deficiency of belief as such. The Trad believer, scared and frustrated, tries to convince the Heckler to believe in sense. I find the easier path is to first get the cynic to believe in nonsense. A deeper, more authentic, and abiding belief in sense may arise naturally.
I understand why both mistakes happen. I feel it in the microcosm of my own internal dramas. I studied philosophy. I like knowing the right things, and the safety and comfort that affords me, and even, occasionally, the transcendence and beauty contained within ideas. The Hyde to that Jekyll is that I’ve always also loved improv comedy. Not everybody is into both philosophy and comedy, but probably everyone has a serious side and a silly side. These two characters have always struggled not to hate each other. The philosopher finds the fool idiotic and lowbrow. The fool finds the philosopher self-serious, pompous, embarrassing. For a long time I wasn’t sure whether I needed to sacrifice one for the other. It only occurred to me recently that this discomfort, this frustration, is built into the suppleness of whatever sanity I’ve managed. Their lack of reconciliation is the point.
The philosopher without a fool is a sophist. The fool without the philosopher is a nihilist who sides with the chaos that always threatens to undo creation. He betrays Being itself merely because his discomfort with the incommensurability between himself and the philosopher is so great that he would go to great extremes to become entirely himself without the other.
This is how people end up either George Carlin or René Descartes. Although they fell off the Tao in opposite directions, both men end up in the same place. Philosophy’s founding joke is that Thales fell to the bottom of the well while looking at the stars while a servant girl laughed at him. He was suffering from an excess of reason, an inability to play. Play is a good metaphor, too, both for the thing children do and for “play” in a machine. The machine is your philosophy of life, and the play is the space allowed between the gears. A machine with play in it is a better machine, one that lasts longer in the real world. The orthodox and the mockers alike have no give. Their gears are too tight and the teeth brittle. The laughing philosopher, let’s say, is best tuned.
My wife, a friend, and I recently started an improv troupe in our little town. We had our first show a week ago. Scared as you are to get up in front of people and try to make them laugh, there’s always the temptation to work too hard for it. Then I remember that one guy and how I can just plainly say what’s going on. Just listen, and then speak to the feelings and tensions in the room. If I give them a name, calmly, truthfully, people will laugh. It takes almost no effort. That doesn’t make it easy. I constantly find myself wanting to be funny and clever in ways that have worked before. Looking back, those are exactly the times when it doesn’t work.
In that way, I lack faith. Faith is believing your fullest participation in Being will lead in the right direction. God is not an arbitrary overlay to protect us from reality. He is reality. Trying to force people to believe in words over direct participation is taking the Lord’s name in vain. Believe in nonsense and you will remember how to believe in sense.
If you’re not laughing, you don’t get it.
Therapy Speak Kills Romance
A husband and wife go to one of the nation’s leading psychiatrists. The husband resisted at the beginning, feeling a little overexposed and humiliated, but these feelings are quickly understood through internalized misogyny, and gently given a psychic playpen to harmlessly express themselves. They both have exceptional careers. He works in finance and she is the owner of a marketing firm. The kids too, are in the best schools and have good college prospects. They are well-adjusted and happy. Every square inch of their lives is filled with something to do, something to consume, something to learn. When the parents started going to therapy, they were fighting a lot. The therapist has them go on weekly dates to re-capture the spark. To her amazement, he now says things like, “I hear and appreciate you,” and “I need to set boundaries for self-care.” They have a date planned that night and it will likely end well. Things are good. And yet, if you looked in their eyes, particularly his, something is




Old and bitter Carlin was definitely less funny for his didactism, but early punny Carlin is hard to beat for his obsession with the sheer absurdity of language and grammar. Werds is a masterclass in extracting fascinating little nuggets out of everyday language.
Providence, I've often told people, works for the funniest outcome.